Insurance carriers, property and casualty, direct · Indiana

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance

Fort Wayne, IN · ~631 workers · 3 years of OSHA Injury Tracking Application data.

F
Failing Safety Record
1.2
Avg TCR
0.5
Industry avg
0
Fatalities
Subscribe to safety-record updates (RSS)

The verdict

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance runs at 244% of its industry's injury rate - far more dangerous than the typical Insurance carriers, property and casualty, direct workplace, earning a grade F.

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance: 1.2 TCR = 244% of Insurance carriers, property and casualty, direct BLS 0.5 · 3y Form 300A (see methodology below)

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance safety composite

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance scores strongest on dart rate (safer than 78% of same-industry peers) and weakest on total case rate (tcr) (safer than 34%), blended into one 0-100 breakdown against same-industry peers. A missing measure drops out and redistributes its weight rather than deflating the score. This is a per-dimension breakdown, distinct from the single letter grade above it (which weights TCR alone against the BLS industry benchmark).

D

54/100

Percentile-weighted across 3 of 3 measures

Total Case Rate (TCR)
F 1.22 per 100 workers

Safer than 34% of industry peers

DART rate
B 0 per 100 workers

Safer than 78% of industry peers

Fatalities
D 0

Safer than 52% of industry peers

Benchmarked live against every credibly-rated employer in the same NAICS industry code in the current OSHA extract (a segment must have at least 8 rated peers to benchmark). Not a legal or compliance determination; PlainSafetyScore's own weighting (TCR 40%, DART 35%, fatalities 25%).

TCR Δ

−1.0

2022→2024

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance injury rate improved

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance's TCR fell 1.0 from 1.9 in 2022 to 0.9 in 2024. Peak filing year was 2022 at 1.9 TCR. In 2024, DART was 0× this establishment's average TCR (severity share of cases).

2022=1.9 · 2023=0.9 · 2024=0.9

OSHA ITA Form 300A scorecard

Establishment book 524126 · Fort Wayne, IN ABOVE-IND · MID

Grade F · TCR 1.2 · 244% of ind

  • DART 0.0 DART
  • RANK P34
  • PHOTO Florida Farm Bureau …
  • BOOK 3y book
  • INJ 17 inj
  • SIZE ~631 FTE

Nearest TCR peer: Florida Farm Bureau Office (0.0 TCR gap)

Read with this employer → · Industry book → · Indiana employers → · Look up another →

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance in the TCR neighbourhood

Average Total Case Rate among this establishment and nearest same-industry peers

TCR

What this shows Brotherhood Mutual Insurance averages 1.2 TCR (244% of the Insurance carriers, property and casualty, direct BLS benchmark).

Source U.S. Department of Labor, OSHA Injury Tracking Application (Form 300A) As of 2026-09-26

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance TCR series: 2022=1.9 · 2023=0.9 · 2024=0.9 · BLS 0.5

Where Brotherhood Mutual Insurance falls in its industry

32 Insurance carriers, property a establishments

Safer than 34% of graded establishments in this industry, whose median TCR is 1.0.

More dangerous than peersSafer than peers
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance (631 employees, TCR 1.2) among 20 same-industry peers, split at the industry median of 282 employees and a TCR of 1.0 2×2 strategic matrix plotting 21 entities by Average employees (X) and Total Case Rate (Y), with a crosshair dividing the plot into four quadrants. Larger & higher-riskSmaller & higher-riskLarger & saferSmaller & safer than peers 05001,0001,5002,000 02468 Average employees Total Case Rate Brotherhood Mutual Insurance
Brotherhood Mutual Insurance (631 employees, TCR 1.2) among 20 same-industry peers, split at the industry median of 282 employees and a TCR of 1.0

Brotherhood Mutual Insurance has more employees than the Insurance carriers, property and casualt median and a higher injury rate than the industry's median TCR of 1.0. Workforce size and injury rate do not always move together within the same industry -- some of its smaller peers run higher rates than its larger ones, and vice versa.

Year-by-Year Safety Data

Year TCR DART Injuries Illnesses Fatalities
2024 0.9 0.0 2 3 0
2023 0.9 0.5 5 0 0
2022 1.9 1.1 10 0 0

OSHA ITA peer cross-reference

Establishment peer ledger

524126 · IN · Fort Wayne

32 Insurance carriers, property and casualty, direct employers nationwide with a credible TCR · 12,750 rated employers in Indiana with headcount on file · 634 employers in Fort Wayne, IN · 4 cross-state NAT-TCR peers · 4 cross-state NAT-SIZE peers. Closest matches by relationship code are listed below.

Rel Establishment Metric
NAICS-TCR Florida Farm Bureau Office 1.2 TCR
NAICS-TCR South Carolina Casualty 1.3 TCR
NAICS-TCR AR Farm Bureau Office 1.3 TCR
NAICS-TCR MS Farm Bureau Office 1.0 TCR
STATE-SIZE IND-ODFL 630 FTE
STATE-SIZE FRANKFORT CORE 632 FTE
STATE-SIZE Plainfield, IN (Whirlpool) 428 632 FTE
STATE-SIZE Seymour Community Schools 633 FTE
CITY-NEAR Parkview Memorial Hospital 6,096 FTE
CITY-NEAR Parkview North Hospital 4,648 FTE
CITY-NEAR Parkview Corporate Office 3,312 FTE
CITY-NEAR Shambaugh & Son LP 3,072 FTE
NAT-TCR Flatiron Dragados Llc 1.2 TCR
NAT-TCR West Pharmaceutical Services, Inc. 1.2 TCR
NAT-TCR Roberts Swiss Inc. 1.2 TCR
NAT-TCR Skyline Electric 1.2 TCR
NAT-SIZE Ventura Foods, LLC. 631 FTE
NAT-SIZE Nailor Industries of Texas 631 FTE
NAT-SIZE Virginia Museum of Fine Arts 631 FTE
NAT-SIZE Coherent Inc. Santa Clara 631 FTE

Rel codes: NAICS-TCR · STATE-SIZE · CITY-NEAR · NAT-TCR/NAT-SIZE cross-state. Read with this employer →

Data Source: OSHA Injury Tracking Application (ITA), mandatory establishment-level injury/illness reports. Grades compare employer Total Case Rate (TCR) to BLS IIF industry benchmarks. Data covers years reported by this establishment: 2024, 2023, 2022. This is publicly available government data - not a legal determination of workplace conditions.

Read our methodology - how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.

Data sourced from official public datasets. See our methodology for details.