Recyclable material collection services · New York
Carmen Barbato, Inc.
Hillsdale, NY · ~31 workers · 9 years of OSHA Injury Tracking Application data.
- F
- Failing Safety Record
- 9.5
- Avg TCR
- 2.6
- Industry avg
- 1
- Fatality
The verdict
Carmen Barbato, Inc. runs at 366% of its industry's injury rate - far more dangerous than the typical Recyclable material collection services workplace, earning a grade F.
Carmen Barbato, Inc.: 9.5 TCR = 366% of Recyclable material collection services BLS 2.6 · 9y Form 300A (see methodology below)
Carmen Barbato, Inc. safety composite
Carmen Barbato, Inc. scores strongest on dart rate (safer than 19% of same-industry peers) and weakest on fatalities (safer than 2%), blended into one 0-100 breakdown against same-industry peers. A missing measure drops out and redistributes its weight rather than deflating the score. This is a per-dimension breakdown, distinct from the single letter grade above it (which weights TCR alone against the BLS industry benchmark).
14/100
Percentile-weighted across 3 of 3 measures
- Total Case Rate (TCR)
- F 9.51 per 100 workers
Safer than 18% of industry peers
- DART rate
- F 7.46 per 100 workers
Safer than 19% of industry peers
- Fatalities
- F 1
Safer than 2% of industry peers
Benchmarked live against every credibly-rated employer in the same NAICS industry code in the current OSHA extract (a segment must have at least 8 rated peers to benchmark). Not a legal or compliance determination; PlainSafetyScore's own weighting (TCR 40%, DART 35%, fatalities 25%).
TCR Δ
−7.0
2016→2024
Carmen Barbato, Inc. injury rate improved
Carmen Barbato, Inc.'s TCR fell 7.0 from 14.5 in 2016 to 7.5 in 2024. Peak filing year was 2018 at 17.2 TCR. In 2024, DART was 0.78× this establishment's average TCR (severity share of cases).
2016=14.5 · 2017=10.5 · 2018=17.2 · 2019=6.2 · 2020=6.7 · 2021=7.1 · 2022=12.2 · 2023=3.8 · 2024=7.5
OSHA ITA Form 300A scorecard
Establishment book 562111 · Hillsdale, NY ABOVE-IND · SMALL
Grade F · TCR 9.5 · 366% of ind
- DART 7.5 DART
- RANK #55/73
- PHOTO Direct Waste Services
- BOOK 9y book
- INJ 25 inj
- SIZE ~31 FTE
Nearest TCR peer: Direct Waste Services (0.0 TCR gap)
Read with this employer → · Industry book → · New York employers → · Look up another →
Carmen Barbato, Inc. in the TCR neighbourhood
Average Total Case Rate among this establishment and nearest same-industry peers
- This site
Carmen Barbato, Inc.
9.5 TCR
- Direct Waste S
Direct Waste Services
9.5 TCR
- Bernardsville
Bernardsville Hauling
9.5 TCR
- Conwaste Canov
Conwaste Canovanas
9.5 TCR
- WASTE RESOURCE
WASTE RESOURCES, INC
9.5 TCR
What this shows Carmen Barbato, Inc. averages 9.5 TCR (366% of the Recyclable material collection services BLS benchmark).
Carmen Barbato, Inc. TCR series: 2016=14.5 · 2017=10.5 · 2018=17.2 · 2019=6.2 · 2020=6.7 · 2021=7.1 · 2022=12.2 · 2023=3.8 · 2024=7.5 · BLS 2.6
Where Carmen Barbato, Inc. falls in its industry
2,322 Recyclable material collection establishmentsSafer than 18% of graded establishments in this industry, whose median TCR is 5.1.
Narrower to New York alone (the establishments it most directly competes with for workers and contracts): ranked #55 safest of 73 Recyclable material collection employers in New York.
Carmen Barbato, Inc. has fewer employees than the Recyclable material collection services median and a higher injury rate than the industry's median TCR of 5.1. Workforce size and injury rate do not always move together within the same industry -- some of its smaller peers run higher rates than its larger ones, and vice versa.
Year-by-Year Safety Data
| Year | TCR | DART | Injuries | Illnesses | Fatalities |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | 7.5 | 7.5 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2023 | 3.8 | 0.0 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| 2022 | 12.2 | 3.0 | 4 | 0 | 1 |
| 2021 | 7.1 | 7.1 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2020 | 6.7 | 3.4 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2019 | 6.2 | 6.2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| 2018 | 17.2 | 13.8 | 5 | 0 | 0 |
| 2017 | 10.5 | 3.5 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
| 2016 | 14.5 | 10.9 | 4 | 0 | 0 |
OSHA ITA peer cross-reference
Establishment peer ledger
562111 · NY · Hillsdale
2,322 Recyclable material collection services employers nationwide with a credible TCR · 21,008 rated employers in New York with headcount on file · 3 employers in Hillsdale, NY · 4 cross-state NAT-TCR peers · 4 cross-state NAT-SIZE peers. Closest matches by relationship code are listed below.
| Rel | Establishment | Metric |
|---|---|---|
| NAICS-TCR | Direct Waste Services | 9.5 TCR |
| NAICS-TCR | Bernardsville Hauling | 9.5 TCR |
| NAICS-TCR | Conwaste Canovanas | 9.5 TCR |
| NAICS-TCR | WASTE RESOURCES, INC | 9.5 TCR |
| STATE-SIZE | Eldred Brothers / Main Farm | 31 FTE |
| STATE-SIZE | Fox Fruit Farms LLC | 31 FTE |
| STATE-SIZE | ASC Kirkwood | 31 FTE |
| STATE-SIZE | NAES : OM - New Athens | 31 FTE |
| CITY-NEAR | Ed Herrington Inc - Hillsdale | 117 FTE |
| CITY-NEAR | Hillsdale | 106 FTE |
| NAT-TCR | Pioneer College Caterers, Inc. - Unit 042/Bryan College | 9.5 TCR |
| NAT-TCR | Buschkoetter's Nursery, Lawn and Garden Center, Inc. | 9.5 TCR |
| NAT-TCR | Cleveland Steel Container Corporation - Streetsboro | 9.5 TCR |
| NAT-TCR | Reel Core Inc. | 9.5 TCR |
| NAT-SIZE | Custom Insulation Co., Inc. | 31 FTE |
| NAT-SIZE | FBF Inc. | 31 FTE |
| NAT-SIZE | SII Lake Charles | 31 FTE |
| NAT-SIZE | Akers Packaging Solutions, Inc | 31 FTE |
Rel codes: NAICS-TCR · STATE-SIZE · CITY-NEAR · NAT-TCR/NAT-SIZE cross-state. Read with this employer →
Read our methodology - how this data is sourced, computed, and verified.